I saw this on the Big Lead first and of course had to check out the article. Mark Bradley is not unhappy that Brett Favre has retired. What Mark Bradley has written is the very opposite of a puff piece, but its not a vindictive Jay Mariotti type piece either. It is the anti-puff piece, written without anger, but with a sense of calm only insanity can give you...but it doesn't mean he is wrong.
You are not alone, I feel like I have seen a lot of Brett Favre interceptions and I want him to stay retired. I don't dislike him but he has overstayed his welcome. Brett Favre has put up some great numbers as a quarterback, but he has left us all emotionally drained from his drama.
Really? Joe Namath will arm wrestle Favre for that crown. Not only is Namath sporting a career completion percentage hardly over 50% but he also has thrown 47 more interceptions than touchdown passes and a career quarterback rating of 65.5. Oh, and he is in the Hall of Fame as one of the greatest players of all time to play football.
Look, Namath is probably lucky he got drunk one night at a Jets game and offered to kiss Suzy Kolber...twice, because he is now known as a guy who got drunk at a football game and made an ass of himself, as opposed to the most overrated quarterback of all time, which is really what he should be known as.
Now he is cherry picking stats, but they are still very true. Anyone who reads this blog knows I am not the biggest Favre fan in the world and some of the numbers that Mark Bradley puts up are the reason. I don't know if I would take him out of the top 10 quarterbacks of all time. It is pretty close in my mind though.
This Kurt Warner love is kind of overboard at this point. Warner has had 5 good seasons and Brett Favre has had 8 seasons that are comparable to Warner and those were all outstanding seasons. Favre has had other seasons where he put up good numbers, while Warner has been benched several times so he has seasons with bad numbers.
I think Favre is a little overrated but he has been a better quarterback over his career than Kurt Warner.
There were times when I wasn't reading a Peter King column that I forgot Favre was still playing, so yes, the league will survive.
That is a Gene W. column about Favre that goes overboard.
Ouch. I feel very similar, just without the idea that Favre was the most overrated of all time.
These excuses for Favre's performance are crappy. He had Jerricho Cotchery, Coles, Thomas Jones, and Dustin Keller. Those were some weapons.
Gene was clearly not paying attention to the NFL at the end of this year. If Favre's shoulder was directly affecting him, then he had other accuracy problems to deal with as well.
No, the Packers were not good this year around Rodgers while the Jets were good around Favre. Rodgers played well this year and Brett Favre did not. The Jets collapse was partially Favre's fault.
I don't know, check out the stats. They aren't bad, but they are not great either.
Knowing Brett Favre, he probably actually took those footballs from the receiver who caught it, then gave it back to the receiver, but later requested the player give it back.
No Brett Favre puff piece is complete without a sentence similar to this one.
I agree and part of his legacy is his interceptions and the problems he caused the fans, the Jets, the Packers and the NFL his last year with his retirement/non-retirement dance.
The only thing worse than Brett Favre love is the kind of recent idea that somehow the last 3 years of Favre's career somehow represents him more than the peak of his career, when he was undoubtedly one of the best 10 QB's ever to play the game.
ReplyDeleteOr maybe it's the other way around. In any case they're both bad things.
Yeah, I am very hard on Brett Favre as a person, but I am not sure I could ever try and argue he is not one of the top 10 quarterbacks of all time. I think that is slightly insane.
ReplyDeleteI am all for hating a person but you have to do it within reason. Favre may be slightly overrated but he is nowhere near as bad as Mark Bradley presents him to be. I do think Favre is a semi-liar though.